Sourmilk and Cupful Show What Can Go Wrong With AI Branding

What the Sourmilk and Cupful controversy teaches businesses about originality, human judgement and brand trust.

Introduction

How original is AI-generated branding?

In November 2026, American Greek yoghurt brand Sourmilk found itself at the centre of a branding controversy after discovering that another business, Cupful, had launched with a remarkably similar visual identity.

The packaging, photography, illustrations and website all bore a striking resemblance to Sourmilk’s existing branding. According to reporting by Inc., Cupful’s founder said she had used artificial intelligence to create the designs.

The incident raises an important question for businesses using AI in their marketing. Who is checking that the work being produced is original, appropriate and safe to publish?

What happened between Sourmilk and Cupful?

Sourmilk founders Kiki Couchman and Elan Halpern were alerted to Cupful after a customer noticed similarities between the two brands.

According to Sourmilk’s first-hand account, Cupful’s packaging featured similar curved white lettering on a royal-blue background. Its website, illustrations and social media content also closely resembled Sourmilk’s existing creative assets.

Sourmilk had spent two years working with independent designers, photographers and illustrators to develop its identity.

Rather than immediately pursuing legal action, the founders shared side-by-side comparisons on social media. Their audience quickly responded, and according to Sourmilk, Cupful’s website and Instagram account disappeared less than 20 minutes later.

The controversy attracted coverage from Inc. and industry publication NOSH, which reported on the similarities and Cupful’s subsequent removal of its online presence.

Cupful founder Shreya Goyal told Inc. that she had used AI to create the branding and was unaware of Sourmilk. She explained that branding wasn’t her area of expertise and that AI had offered an affordable alternative to hiring an agency.

Goyal denied intending to imitate Sourmilk, apologised and said she planned to relaunch with a new identity.

The exact prompts and reference materials used to generate Cupful’s branding haven’t been established publicly, so it’s unclear how the similarities arose.

However, the case highlights a risk that businesses need to take seriously.

AI-generated doesn’t automatically mean original

AI has made professional-looking branding more accessible, particularly for smaller businesses with limited budgets.

Logos, packaging concepts, website designs and marketing imagery can now be produced quickly and at relatively little cost.

That’s useful, but there’s a difference between generating a design and establishing that it’s suitable for commercial use.

AI tools can produce polished creative work without verifying whether the result closely resembles an existing brand or incorporates protected material.

As The Fashion Law explains in its analysis of the Sourmilk and Cupful controversy, businesses adopting AI-generated packaging, logos or imagery can still face intellectual property disputes.

The UK government’s March 2026 report on copyright and artificial intelligence also demonstrates how questions of creative ownership, AI-generated outputs and copyright enforcement remain an important area of policy development.

The technology used to create something doesn’t automatically remove the responsibility of the business publishing it.

The Advertising Standards Authority has also confirmed that existing UK advertising rules apply regardless of whether content has been produced by a person or generated using AI.

Visual similarity doesn’t automatically establish copyright or trade mark infringement, and the reporting on Sourmilk and Cupful does not establish a legal finding against Cupful.

But the potential consequences extend beyond legal disputes.

There’s also the reputational damage of appearing to copy another business.

For a start-up trying to establish credibility, that can be particularly damaging.

Good branding needs more than a good-looking design

One of the biggest risks with AI-generated branding is that businesses focus on the finished visuals without considering the strategy behind them.

A distinctive brand is built around its audience, positioning, personality and commercial objectives.

Its visual identity should communicate what makes the business different.

Sourmilk’s branding was the result of deliberate creative decisions made with designers, photographers and illustrators. The consistency across its packaging, website and social content helped establish a recognisable identity.

AI can support this process, but it doesn’t replace the need to understand why those decisions are being made.

The Chartered Institute of Public Relations has published research and guidance examining the role of AI in communications, including the continued importance of human expertise, professional judgement and responsible implementation.

At Lala Comms, we’ve explored similar challenges in Who’s Guarding the Brand in the Age of AI?, looking at why human oversight is becoming increasingly important as automated content becomes more widespread.

Without that thinking, businesses risk producing generic identities or following existing creative styles too closely.

Looking professional isn’t the same as being distinctive.

And when every business has access to similar creative tools, differentiation becomes even more important.

Sourmilk’s response shows the value of brand loyalty

There’s another important communications lesson in this story.

Sourmilk’s audience was quick to support the business after its founders shared the comparisons.

Customers commented, shared the content and helped bring wider attention to the situation.

According to a follow-up report from Packaged Goods, the initial social media response attracted more than 500 comments within a few hours.

The publication also highlighted another branding dispute involving boxed wine brand Juliet, whose founder described a similar experience involving marketing imagery allegedly reproduced with AI.

This suggests that concerns about AI-assisted imitation aren’t limited to the Sourmilk case.

In its 8 November newsletter, Sourmilk acknowledged that the experience had been frustrating but had also introduced the company to new audiences and demonstrated the strength of its community.

That response wasn’t simply the result of having recognisable packaging.

Sourmilk had invested in communicating its story, sharing its progress and building relationships with its customers.

When the brand was challenged, those relationships mattered.

It’s a useful reminder that branding is about more than visual assets.

You can imitate a design, but you can’t instantly replicate the trust a business has built with its audience.

For businesses investing in communications, that distinction is significant.

What businesses should consider before publishing AI-generated branding

The lesson isn’t to stop using AI. It’s to make sure the appropriate checks are in place.

Research the market.

Review competitor identities and existing creative work before committing to a design. Understanding what’s already out there is essential to creating something distinctive.

For businesses operating in the US, the United States Patent and Trademark Office recommends conducting comprehensive clearance searches to identify potentially conflicting trade marks.

Check intellectual property.

The UK Intellectual Property Office’s trade mark search provides a starting point for identifying registered marks.

The UK government’s copyright guidance also confirms that original illustrations, photography and other creative works can receive automatic copyright protection.

For businesses incorporating existing images into AI-assisted work, the government’s guidance on digital images and photographs explains important considerations around ownership, permissions and licensing.

These checks don’t guarantee that a design is free from infringement risks, but they are important steps in the process.

Review the creative process.

Keep records of AI prompts, reference materials and asset permissions.

Businesses should understand how their branding was developed and what materials have been used to create it.

Apply human judgement.

An experienced designer, brand strategist or communications professional can assess whether the work is distinctive, relevant and aligned with the business’s objectives.

The CIPR’s guidance on responsible AI use provides further resources for communications professionals navigating these decisions.

These checks don’t need to make branding unnecessarily complicated or expensive. They help businesses avoid launching an identity that creates problems later.

Conclusion

AI is a tool, not a brand strategy

At Lala Comms, we’ve previously explored the importance of putting people at the centre of communications in Humans First Bots Second. The Sourmilk and Cupful controversy demonstrates why that approach matters. AI can improve efficiency, reduce production costs and help businesses explore creative possibilities. Used well, it can be a valuable part of the branding process. But it still needs direction. Businesses need to know what they want their brand to communicate, who they’re trying to reach and what makes them different from their competitors. They also need someone with the experience to question the output rather than simply approve it. The problem isn’t businesses using AI to create branding. It’s businesses using AI without properly reviewing what it creates. And as AI becomes a bigger part of marketing, that distinction will only become more important. At Lala Comms, we help businesses develop distinctive brands and communications strategies that support their commercial goals. Explore our brand development and marketing services.

Subscribe to our newsletter

La La Communications Ltd Copyright ©2025

Subscribe to our newsletter

La La Communications Ltd Copyright ©2025

Subscribe to our newsletter

La La Communications Ltd Copyright ©2025